- Media Buying Consulting Newsletter
- Posts
- You’re Not Competing With Brands. You’re Competing With Gossip.
You’re Not Competing With Brands. You’re Competing With Gossip.
You’re up against:
– A TikTok breakup saga with 2 million views
– Leaked Slack messages from a toxic startup founder
– A Reddit thread accusing a beauty brand of secretly reformulating their hero product
– Some influencer crying in their car on Instagram
And you think your "Save 20% now!" ad is gonna win attention?
The Real Attention Economy is Powered by Gossip
Not literally. But close.
What actually pulls people in?
Conflict. Uncertainty. Tribal drama. Whispers. WTF energy.
We are biologically wired to prioritize social threat and in-group hierarchy.
That’s why we click on drama first — and scroll past rational offers like they’re Terms & Conditions.
What This Means for You
If your ad doesn't contain a little friction, a little tension, a little "wait, what?" energy...
…it dies.
Or worse — it gets politely ignored.
Here’s how to fix that:
Make Your Ad a Test People Want to Take
“We ran two versions of this. One crushed. One tanked. Guess which one.”
That’s mystery. Challenge. Curiosity.
Use Tribal Language
“Most marketers won’t tell you this, but…”
“If you still believe this myth, you’re losing money.”
That’s in-group vs. out-group tension — and it works because no one wants to feel like the sucker.
Make the Stakes Emotional
“This brand got roasted on Twitter. Their sales 3X’d anyway.”
That’s conflict with a twist — drama with a business payoff.
What to Avoid
Facts with no tension
Value props with no hook
“Helpful” content with zero stakes
Being helpful is nice. But attention comes first.
And in the content-saturated hellscape we live in, gossip > guidance every time.
Your Takeaway
If your ad wouldn’t be whispered behind someone’s back, it won’t get clicked on.
The brands that win aren't just relevant — they're rumor-worthy.
Write like you're trying to get screenshotted.
—Peter